Cafe Ollie, Ypsilanti, MI

Caprese sandwich (vegetarian) from Cafe Ollie

I was sad to see Cafe Luwak in Depot Town leave, but I was thrilled to see another eatery take its place quickly. Like Cafe Luwak, Cafe Ollie serves a number of sandwiches, comfort foods, baked goods and coffee drinks. Cafe Ollie has split their menu into thrids to appeal to carnivores, vegetarians and vegans.

I’ve ordered take-out twice in the last couple of weeks. The first time I stopped in I found the counter staff helpful and ready to chat. I also found it to be a bit darker in the revamped deli area. On that visit I tried something from the carnivore’s menu ā€“ the T-Hill ā€“ a turkey sandwich with thick smoked meat, cucumber slices, Monterrey Jack, and ranch dressing on sourdough bread. The turkey tasted like it was carved right off a Thanksgiving bird and the cucumbers gave the sandwich a nice crunch. Overall, I thought it was tasty, but lacking something I can’t quite put my finger on, maybe some tomato or lettuce for color?

My husband was kind enough to pick up The Crazy Caprese vegetarian sandwich for me the other night. He made the same comment to me that the lighting seemed a bit dim when he stopped in. My version had fresh mozzarella, fresh basil and a balsamic drizzle on a fresh ciabatta roll. On the menu, the bread is said to be flavored with sun-dried tomatoes, I was a little disappointed that on that day it was just simple white ciabatta for me, but the roll was fresh and still flavorful. I thought the rest of the ingredients were good quality and delicious too.

All sandwiches are served with potato chips and the ones at Cafe Ollie are addictive. I’m not a big potato chip fan, but these aren’t greasy or too salty and they were cut to a perfect thickness. I’ll have to ask if they’re made in-house next time I go.

Given that Ypsilanti has a limited selection of independently owned restaurants that offer a refreshing menu, Cafe Ollie seems to be a nice addition to Depot Town.